Outrageous Predictions
Die Grüne Revolution der Schweiz: 30 Milliarden Franken-Initiative bis 2050
Katrin Wagner
Head of Investment Content Switzerland
The Bloomberg Commodity Total Return Index (BCOMTR) is heading for a sixth consecutive weekly decline, capping what has been one of the most challenging months for the commodity sector since 2022. The index has lost around 12% since reaching a record high last month, with almost every major sector contributing to the correction.
The breadth of the selloff has been striking. Precious metals have led the decline, followed by energy and industrial metals, while agricultural markets have generally softened as well. Only the weather-driven soft commodity sector has managed to buck the trend, with cocoa posting strong gains amid renewed supply concerns.
The speed and scale of the correction should not in our opinion be mistaken for a broad deterioration in commodity fundamentals. Instead, June has been characterised by a rapid repricing of geopolitical risk, monetary policy expectations and speculative positioning after several markets had become increasingly crowded on the long side.
The biggest catalyst behind June's commodity reset has been the dramatic shift in expectations surrounding the Middle East. For months, the closure of the Strait of Hormuz represented the single largest supply disruption ever experienced in the modern oil market, removing well over one billion barrels of production from global trade while forcing consumers to draw heavily on both commercial inventories and strategic reserves.
The US-Iran peace agreement fundamentally changed that narrative. Instead of focusing on missing barrels, traders suddenly began pricing the return of stranded crude cargoes, recovering Gulf exports and improving tanker traffic through one of the world's most important shipping lanes. The result has been a sharp reversal in oil prices despite global inventories remaining historically depleted.
In many respects, the oil market has transitioned from crisis pricing to clearance pricing. The release of stranded barrels has created a temporary wall of near-term supply that physical markets must absorb through higher refinery runs, storage or exports before underlying fundamentals once again become the dominant driver.
This helps explain why crude prices have fallen despite little change to the longer-term supply outlook. Commercial inventories remain well below historical averages, strategic reserves have yet to be rebuilt following record drawdowns, and restoring shut-in production across the region may take considerably longer than financial markets assume.
The energy correction has also spilled into several commodities that had benefited from elevated geopolitical risk premiums. While crude prices have fallen, the pass-through to fuel prices has been slower, as tight refined product inventories and strong seasonal demand continue to support refining margins and keep prices at the pump elevated.
As the charts below highlight, US gasoline crack spreads remain elevated despite the recent easing in crude prices. The biggest beneficiary of the reopening of Middle East export flows has so far been the distillate market, with gasoil and diesel cracks falling from their March peaks. This reflects the fact that much of the additional crude now reaching the market is medium-to-heavy Gulf crude, which yields a higher proportion of middle distillates such as diesel, gasoil and jet fuel.
While geopolitics drove the first leg of June's correction, macroeconomics provided the second. The Federal Reserve's latest policy meeting reinforced its determination to maintain restrictive monetary policy as inflation remains above target. Markets responded by raising expectations for further policy tightening while simultaneously rewarding the Fed's inflation-fighting credibility. The result has been lower long-end yields while the dollar has reached its strongest level in more than a year.
Historically, few macro variables matter more for commodities than the dollar. Since most raw materials are priced in US dollars, a stronger currency mechanically tightens financial conditions for international consumers while simultaneously reducing investment demand across the commodity complex.
The interesting nuance this month has been the behaviour of the Treasury market. Short-term yields have remained elevated as investors priced additional policy tightening, while longer-dated yields have eased as markets increasingly believe today's restrictive policy and the slump in energy costs will eventually succeed in slowing inflation.
That combination has created an especially difficult backdrop for commodities, particularly precious metals that generate no income and industrial metals whose demand outlook remains closely tied to global manufacturing activity. In many respects, the inflation ghost has not disappeared, but at the same time the market may soon begin to question whether peak hawkishness has already been reached. Lower energy prices are likely to ease inflation over time, potentially reducing pressure on the Fed to hike rates and creating the conditions for a renewed tailwind through a softer dollar and more stable, rather than rising, funding costs.
Gold has extended its correction after breaking below several important technical support levels, triggering another round of long liquidation from institutional investors and short selling by speculative traders. While central bank demand remains robust and geopolitical uncertainty continues to provide an important longer-term pillar of support, these structural factors have temporarily been overwhelmed by dollar strength and rising real funding costs.
Silver has performed even worse.
As both a precious and industrial metal, silver has effectively suffered from the worst of both worlds. Weak investor appetite for precious metals has coincided with softer sentiment towards economically sensitive industrial metals, making silver the weakest performer across the major commodity sectors during June.
Copper tells a similar story.
The recent decline appears far more technical than fundamentally driven. The break below key support levels forced commodity trading advisors and hedge funds to reduce long exposure, accelerating price weakness even as exchange inventories continue to decline and physical demand remains relatively resilient.
In our opinion, there has been little meaningful change to the long-term investment case. Electrification, grid expansion, artificial intelligence infrastructure, data centres, electric vehicles and renewable energy continue to require significantly more copper than current mine investment is likely to deliver over the coming decade.
Aluminium has similarly been caught between easing Middle East supply concerns and a broader reduction in investor risk appetite, despite demand from transportation, packaging and the energy transition remaining supportive over the longer term.
Perhaps the clearest explanation for the magnitude of June's correction lies in speculative positioning. Commodity markets entered the month with hedge funds holding some of their largest bullish positions in years following strong gains across energy, precious metals and several agricultural markets.
That positioning has now undergone a dramatic reset. The combined managed-money net long position across 24 major commodity futures has fallen from more than 1.8 million contracts at its April peak to around 620,000 contracts in the latest reporting week ending 16 June.
The liquidation has been broad-based, with energy positions cut sharply as supply returned and geopolitical risk premiums evaporated. Precious metals have been exposed to dollar strength and a deterioration technical outlook, while industrial metals led by aluminum have suffered from systematic selling following technical breakdowns. The agriculture sector has been among the hardest hit, particularly grains, where investors have reduced exposure amid improving weather conditions and stronger crop prospects. Over the past six weeks, as the BCOM Grains Index fell 7.5%, the combined hedge fund net long across six major contracts tracked collapsed by 90% from a record 874,000 contracts, with corn seeing the biggest reduction, flipping from a sizable long to a small net short.
With these major changes in mind, it is important to note that positioning has become an amplifier rather than merely a reflection of changing fundamentals. When technical support levels are broken, systematic funds and momentum traders often accelerate price moves regardless of whether underlying supply and demand have materially changed. That dynamic helps explain why several commodities have experienced corrections that appear disproportionate to the evolution of their physical markets.
While the short-term environment has clearly deteriorated, we continue to believe the strategic case for commodities remains compelling. The structural forces supporting higher raw material demand have not disappeared simply because markets have experienced a difficult month.
The global economy continues to move from a "just-in-time" supply model towards a more resilient "just-in-case" framework. Companies and governments alike are increasingly prioritising security of supply over maximum efficiency, encouraging higher inventories, regional manufacturing capacity and greater redundancy throughout critical supply chains.
At the same time, geopolitical fragmentation and deglobalisation continue to reshape investment priorities. Governments are directing increasing amounts of capital towards defence, strategic infrastructure and domestic manufacturing, all of which are exceptionally commodity intensive.
The global energy transition remains another powerful source of long-term demand growth. Expanding electricity grids, renewable power generation, battery storage, electric vehicles and the enormous investment required to decarbonise heavy industry will consume unprecedented quantities of copper, aluminium, nickel, silver and numerous other industrial materials over the coming decades.
Power demand itself is entering a new structural growth phase. Artificial intelligence, cloud computing and hyperscale data centres are significantly increasing electricity consumption, while higher global temperatures continue to drive rising cooling demand. Electrification of transport and heating further reinforces this trend.
Demographics provide another important pillar of support. Population growth, urbanisation and rising living standards across many developing economies continue to increase demand for housing, infrastructure, transportation and consumer goods - all highly resource-intensive activities.
Climate change is also becoming an increasingly important commodity driver. More frequent weather extremes are disrupting agricultural production, mining operations and energy infrastructure while simultaneously increasing investment requirements across adaptation and resilience projects.
Finally, an equally important supporting factor remains chronic underinvestment. Years of capital discipline, ESG uncertainty, permitting challenges and rising project costs have left mining and energy industries struggling to develop sufficient new supply capacity. Discoveries of major mineral deposits continue to decline, project development timelines are lengthening, and securing financing for large-scale extraction projects has become increasingly difficult.
June has been a painful month for commodities, but it should not be mistaken for a clean rejection of the structural bull case. The market has repriced a rapid improvement in Middle East supply risks, a more hawkish Fed, a stronger dollar and the liquidation of crowded speculative longs.
Near term, the dollar, US inflation data, Fed pricing and the speed at which Gulf barrels clear will remain the primary drivers of commodity prices. Volatility is also likely to remain elevated as positioning continues to normalise following one of the sharpest speculative reductions seen in recent years.
Medium term, however, our constructive view remains unchanged. Depleted inventories, fragile supply chains, chronic underinvestment and multiple structural demand drivers - including electrification, power infrastructure, defence spending, deglobalisation, urbanisation and climate adaptation - continue to argue for a tighter commodity landscape over the coming years. While June has undoubtedly been a month of adjustment, we believe it represents a positioning reset rather than the beginning of a new structural bear market for commodities.
| More from the author |
|---|
|