Cocoa slump saves the chocolate bar – but not your Christmas treats

Summary

• Cocoa futures have fallen to ~USD 5,000/t, a 21-month low and more than 50% off the peak, though still roughly twice their long-term average.
• Market structure has flipped from extreme backwardation to mild contango, signalling a major easing in supply tightness.
• High prices triggered both demand destruction (shrinkflation, dilution) and a strong supply response across West Africa and emerging origins.
• The drop comes too late to improve Christmas chocolate, but next year’s Easter eggs may benefit.

---

Cocoa’s spectacular reversal continues to gather pace as futures slump toward USD 5,000/t — the lowest level in nearly two years and more than 50% below the 2024 peak above USD 12,000. Even so, cocoa remains historically elevated, still trading at roughly double its long-term average. The shift marks a decisive unwinding of an unprecedented supply squeeze and a broader normalisation across the value chain.

 

The retreat reflects a classic case of “the best cure for high prices is high prices.” After several years of weather disruptions, disease pressure and ageing trees in Ivory Coast and Ghana, the world’s two dominant producers, the 2023–24 deficit pushed physical supply to breaking point. Crucially, farmgate prices lagged the futures spike, leaving farmers unable to invest just as climate volatility was intensifying. This mismatch created the conditions for the parabolic rise.

That dynamic is now reversing. Improved rainfall, better fertiliser use and rising producer-country prices have encouraged farmers to rehabilitate plantations, prune more aggressively and replant high-yielding varieties. Beyond West Africa, elevated returns have sparked investment in Latin America and Southeast Asia, gradually broadening the global supply base.

This transition is visible in the forward curve. One year ago, the Dec-24 futures contract traded in New York held a 23% premium over Dec-25, an extreme backwardation that highlighted acute nearby scarcity. Today, Dec-25 trades at a USD 270/t or 5.5% discount to Dec-26, reflecting a return to contango and a market that is no longer scrambling for prompt supply. Producers are again willing to hedge, inventories are starting to recover and traders are no longer paying panic-level premiums to secure beans.

Demand has also played an essential role in normalising the balance. Record-high raw material costs forced chocolate manufacturers into a series of unpopular choices: shrinkflation, price increases and the quiet dilution of cocoa content. The latter has become sufficiently widespread that some UK biscuits and bars can no longer legally be labelled “chocolate,” instead qualifying only as “chocolate flavour” coatings dominated by palm and shea oils. This is classic demand destruction — the point at which consumers either trade down or manufacturers reformulate to protect margins.

Lower cocoa prices will not immediately reverse shrinkflation or dilution. Recipe reformulations tend to stick, at least for a while. Reversing them requires either competitive pressure or a sustained period of lower input costs. But the potential is now there. Cocoa at USD 5,000/t is still expensive by past standards but far more manageable for manufacturers than USD 12,000/t.

Seasonality adds a timely twist. The current slump arrives far too late to affect Christmas assortments already produced and priced months ago. The supply shock hit during the production cycle for 2024 holiday products, meaning consumers will still face high prices and—depending on the brand—lighter bars with more palm oil than they might expect. But if the market stabilises around current levels, the impact could show up in 2026’s Easter eggs and bunnies. In a market where humour is often in short supply, it is tempting to say that while the cocoa slump won’t save Christmas, it may soften the blow for Easter.

From a trading perspective, the picture now looks considerably more balanced than it did a few months ago. The froth that characterised the peak has largely evaporated, evident in the sharp contraction in aggregate open interest as speculative positions were unwound. The recent stabilisation and modest uptick in open interest likely reflect a mix of fresh speculative selling and renewed producer hedging as prices return to more workable levels. With the parabolic phase behind us, price action should increasingly be driven by more conventional fundamentals: West African weather patterns, disease management, the pace of replanting and political risk in key producer nations. On the demand side, global growth trends, consumer sentiment and the extent to which manufacturers restore cocoa content will shape the recovery profile.

The next key question is sustainability. Can the new supply momentum be maintained? West Africa remains vulnerable to climate variability, and gains in new origins may be too small to offset problems if a serious weather event hits the region again. Meanwhile, if manufacturers do not reverse shrinkflation or dilution, demand may not rebound as quickly thereby keeping a ceiling on prices.

Overall, cocoa’s downturn marks the start of normalisation after a once-in-a-generation shock. The slump has stabilised the market, given farmers breathing room and eased pressure on buyers. For consumers, the benefits are coming — just not in time to salvage this year’s Christmas stockings. But Easter? That might finally bring a bit more real chocolate and a bit less “chocolate-flavoured” improvisation.