Higher earnings predictability drives valuation premium
Head of Equity Strategy
Summary: In this equity research note we take a look at earnings predictability. We find the higher earnings predictability comes with higher valuation. We also find that S&P 500 have higher frequency of companies with high earnings predictability compared to STOXX 600 in Europe. Combining higher earnings predictability and higher earnings growth of US companies compared to those in Europe we can get an idea of why investors are preferring US equities over European equities. We also discuss Adobe and Accenture, two companies with high earnings predictability that still have very different valuations.
In a recent research note we showed that under low interest dynamics valuation could drastically increase and we used Microsoft as an example. We hypothesized that aggressive valuations did not only require low interest rates but also predictable earnings so that the stock mimics a bond income stream. In today’s research note we show that higher earnings predictability increases the forward valuation premium in the equity market, and we show how the S&P 500 has a higher frequency of companies with high degree of earnings predictability.
Highest earnings predictability comes with 30% valuation premium
If we combine all the companies in the S&P 500 with those in the STOXX 600 index and group them by their earnings predictability (R-squared of EPS – definition is explained further down) then an interesting pattern emerges. Higher earnings predictability is rewarded by higher forward valuation. The 10% of companies with the highest earnings predictability have a 12-month forward EV/EBITDA metric that is 30% above the overall US equity market. This means that earnings predictability is a quality factor that explains some of the variance in valuations, but other factors such as business models, geographic footprint, earnings growth and return on invested capital may also help explaining the variance in valuations.
Our future analysis of earnings predictability will look into whether earnings predictability drives future returns across equities.
S&P 500 companies have higher earnings predictability
If we plot the relative frequency of R-squared brackets of 2%-points, then we clearly see that the S&P 500 has a higher degree of companies with high earnings predictability compared to the STOXX 600 index. This is driven by the higher concentration of information technology companies in the S&P 500 which are dominated by software companies. Higher earnings predictability is a defensive characteristic as the certainty over futures earnings goes up and this can explain why investors have preferred US companies over European companies. If we combine the higher earnings predictability of S&P 500 with the fact of higher earnings growth over the past 10 years, then we have the recipe for the enormous outperformance of US equities over European equities.
Accenture vs Adobe
Earnings predictability can explain some of the variance in valuations but within each decile of R-squared we observe large differences. Accenture and Adobe have R-squared metrics of 0.993 and 0.983 respectively but Accenture is only valued at 17.6x on 12-month forward EV/EBITDA whereas Adobe is valued at 31.4x on the same valuation metric. While both valuation metrics are far higher than the average of the equity market their large difference indicates that other crucial factors can explain valuation. If we look at earnings growth, we observe that Adobe’s earnings have grown by 17.5% annualized since 2011 whereas Accenture has grown earnings by around 8% annualized. In other words, a high earnings predictability is not worth as much if the growth rate is 3% as for utilities compared to a highly scalable software company such as Adobe.
The table above shows the ten largest companies in the S&P 500 and STOXX 600, and their respective earnings predictability. The market cap weighted average shows that the largest companies in the S&P 500 have a much higher earnings predictability than the largest companies in the STOXX 600 index. This difference is largely explained by the US technology companies such as Apple, Facebook and Google.
How is earnings predictability defined?
The earnings predictability is defined by the R-squared metric which describes the fraction of variance in the dependent variable that can be explained by the independent variable. In this case the dependent variable is the earnings per share from continued operations over the past 20 quarters, 10 semi-annuals or 5 yearly earnings per share numbers depending on the reporting frequency. The independent variable is time. The metric goes from zero to one where one indicates that EPS fits perfectly linear over time and thus if the relationship holds future EPS is easily predictable from the past. In this analysis we removed financials as the valuation metric EV/EBITDA is not measurable for this sector.
Latest Market Insights
Quarterly Outlook Q3 2022: The Runaway Train
- Central banks' attempts to kill inflation is a paradigm shift, which could end in a deep recession.
Tangible assets and profitable growth are the winnersWith US equities officially in a bear market, the big question is where and when is the bottom in the current drawdown?
Understanding the lack of investment appetite among oil majorsThe everything rally seen in recent quarters has become more uneven, as its strength is driven by commodities in short supply.
The pressure is on as the wind leaves the sailsWith cryptocurrencies in sharp decline, are we entering a crypto winter or is the bear market a healthy clean-up of the crypto space?
Why the Fed can never catch up and what turns the US dollar lower?Many other central banks are set to eventually outpace the Fed in hiking rates, taking their real interest rates to levels higher than the Fed will achieve.
Bank of Japan: Swimming against the tideThe Japanese economy has gone from the age of deflation to rapidly rising prices in no time, leaving the Bank of Japan in a pickle.
Green transformation detour and bear market hibernationWith the impending risk of global econonomic derailment, we share the five things investors need to consider in this new half year.
Crisis redux for the eurozone?Whether there's going to be a recession in Europe or not, the path towards a stable economy will be agonizing.
Technical Outlook: Gold, Oil and a remarkable multi-decade perspective on EquitiesThe Nasdaq bubble pattern, USDJPY resistance, crude oil uptrend losing steam and the technical outlook for USD.
China: the train of new development paradigm left the station two years agoChina is transiting to a new development paradigm, as they are hit by deteriorating terms of trade, a slower global economy and an uncertain future while continuing attempts to contain the pandemic.