Post-Game Thoughts & Ring-Side Cornering on the 1st US Presidential Debate: Tactically lift the risk-off move + fade the dollar?
Summary: Macro Reflections: KVP takes stock of some initial thoughts post the first of three presidential debates (we'll also have a VP one next wk), weighing in on what was in-line, some surprises, as well some continued ring-side coaching for both Team Red & Team Blue. Markets sold off in the Asia session post the debate, yet tactically speaking KVP feels this is likely to reverse across risk-assets as Europe & the US come in later today.
Post-Game Thoughts & Ring-Side Cornering on the 1st US Presidential Debate: Tactically lift the risk-off move + fade the dollar?
One Down, Three Debates to go…
- We highlighted one of the key events this wk, with today’s earlier Macro Dragon: Count-Down... in the Red Corner, the Orange Sensation... in the Blue Corner, the Pushup Machine
- What was interesting was on Tue’s Dragon, we gave an overview of what KVP would have coached each corner & coincidently or not (does the Dragon get picked up at the WH or/& by Biden’s Team?) we saw quite a few of those strategies & tactics play out, whilst other fail.
- Before getting into a summary of initial thoughts, takeaways & suggestions. Its once again worth noting that members of each camp are notoriously tribal & the debates are not likely to have anyone change their colors, but for the undecided voters out there (which is pretty mind boggling to KVP, i.e. what else do you need to see to decide, the coming of the Messiah, aliens land, like seriously…anyone lets not digress) perhaps there was a skew to one camp over another.
- Whilst turbulent & at times unintelligible let alone incomprehensible, the debate was actually not as chaotic as KVP thought it could be. Trump was relatively constrained on the broad range that he is capable of, & the moderator – always a tough & super underrated job – Chris Wallace, was masterful, whilst generally quite fair in policing the two speakers
- Format was roughly based around questions & topical segments, with each candidate having 1-2min to give their take, with also sporadic freestyle of coming back to what the other said
- The pros for the dems is, it is an obvious area of mass improvement for Biden going forward over the next two debates. The pros for the reps, this is an obvious area to keep carpet bombing & don’t let the moderator save Biden next time with a shift to the next topic.
- A few things that were perhaps not so surprising:
- We did get plenty of interruptions & talking over one another, with Trump being the dominant culprit
- Trump managed to get under Biden’s skin on exactly what we had coached yesterday, through his son & Ukraine. What was surprising however, is this was done at least on 3 different occasions & it clearly rattled Biden – who in addition to losing a son years
- Trump generally had the same composure, style & greater endurance throughout – in a word, consistency. Biden had a lot more fluctuations.
- Saw the usual suspect topics covered: Economy, Jobs, Taxes, Billionaires, Race Issues in America, Climate Crisis, Courts & Judges, Law & Order, Riots & Protests, Election Ballots, Coronavirus (Trump used “Chinese Plague”!) & its handling, Obi Care (The Affordable Care Act [ACA], commonly referred to as Obama Care albeit millions of Americans likely think are different) as well as response on election outcome.
- Trump easily dodging the pin of allegedly paying $750 in federal taxes in 2016 & 2017, as well as explicitly asking the far right & white supremacist to stop. [Interestingly enough, they discussed Antifa & Biden should have been asked to do the same – albeit he advocated a number of times that protests should be peaceful & not violent)
- Generally speaking both Biden & Trump played to their character, the first following rules & asking a few times for his time to be given back, whilst the later taking as he saw fit.
Some Similarities & Divergences:
- Everyone had diagonally striped ties, including the excellent moderator Chris Wallace. Perhaps a safer bet than say Trump stick to red or Biden to blue. What’s the psychology here? Hard to say, seems to be a conservative middle ground of sorts..
- Both speakers had the American flag pinned on their left chest. Biden also spotted a white pocket square. Trump’s suit higher quality, yet refrigerator cut to Biden’s slimmer cut.
- For the first c. 40-45min, Biden was really on point – focusing on his game, not getting baited by Trump & talking into the camera towards the American people. Clearly he had had his Wheaties for dinner! Trump on the other hand, primarily talked either directly to Biden or the moderator.
- At c. 45min in, Trump starts to get under Biden’s skin with his son’s dealings linked to Ukraine & Russia – this would also happen later towards the end of debate & continued to clearly ruffle Biden’s feathers, diluting his segments.
- Biden did get the number right +200K not 200m (hear that? Huge sigh of relief from his camp & a damn! from the other)
- Biden started strongly, faltered a few times about 2/3 in & finished as well as one can. Trump was pretty even Chen through it all.
- Biden still managed to get a number of key segment of both getting his point across of how a Biden Presidency would be different, whilst also diluting Trump’s track record. Biden went all-in on the need for green infrastructure.
- ‘Jab of the Night’: Trump to Biden… “I’ve done more in 47 months than you have done in 47 years…”
- The “consensus” take is likely to be an equal exchange between the two – with each tribe seeing its own victory – yet if not for Trump getting under Biden’s skin, it would likely have skewed slightly in Biden’s favor.
- With all due respect to his family & by no means advocating that empathy is not a key virtue, because it is & very much lacking in todays world – yet at the end of the day, as POTUS you have 330m Americans & the ability to affect billions globally, you cannot let someone like Trump rattle you, repeatedly, in an area that you knew was going to get attacked. You either have to completely disengage & stick to your script, or you have to go for the jugular – i.e. its not like Trump’s stable of children are a church choir.
- Link to the debate, kicks off at c. 1hr 3min
Next Debate Dates:
- Wed 7 Oct: Vice President Debate, Pence vs. Harris
- Thu 15 Oct: 2nd Presidential Debate, Trump vs. Biden
- Thu 22 Oct: 3rd Presidential Debate, Trump vs. Biden
- Early days as the debate kicked off Asia morning (0900-1040 SGT / 2100-22-40 ET), yet as S&P futures pretty much sold off as it wrapped up & we are now sitting at the lows of the day at c. -0.70% at 3310. The high of the session was c. 3358, a c. +0.75% move from the previous day.
- The USD at least through the DXY is basically the inverse of the S&P futures chart, with the likes of AUDJPY 75.083 -0.30%, AUDUSD 0.7117 -0.18%, USDJPY 105.51 -0.14%, EURUSD 1.1734 -0.09% moving with the S&P.
- Again to KVP, this is just noise & he’d be lifting the dip in US EQ futures & fading the dollar strength – note we also had strong beat on China official PMIs 0900 SGT with Mfg. PMI at 51.5a 51.3e 51.0p & Serv. 55.9a 54.7e 55.2p – Again China is outperforming vs RoW.
- US 10yr bond futures are back to the highs of the session at 139-23+, -0.03%.
- Commodities like oil 40.57 -1.12%, gold 1891 -0.40%, silver 23.88 -1.30%& 298.75 -0.08%copper are at the lows of the session.
- Tactically, think today there is greater than 50% probability that we reverse the risk-off bearish sentiment that came through the back of the debate. Lets see how the European & US session trade.
Improvements - Cornering Team Red + Team Blue
- Team Trump: Keeping doing what you are doing, double down on getting down under Biden’s skin – clearly Biden has a chink in his amour when it comes to his son (family), Ukraine & Russian dealings, etc. Step up the jabs – go after his slip ups… “Joe is it 20, 200million or 20 thousand… because you can’t seem to count… Joe you need a nap, isn’t past your bedtime”. Also surprised you did not bring up any of the complaints & allegations by women against Biden – yep you have your closet as well, but you are the Teflon Don.
- And keep ducking & weaving on any direction questions on taxes, covid-19 response, etc. Play up your tough stance on China, as well as the blame game that you played well earlier this year. Re-Highlight the “witch hunt” how much in American tax payers money was spent on that & for what?
- Go full on Trump and occasionally, just yell out to Biden & the moderator “Your fired!”. Again, no one’s understands as perfect as you, that its all about spin its not about the facts. Walk around the stage like you own it.
- Cancel the VP debate at the very last minute, end of the day, Harris is going to go through Pence like an Killer Whale through a baby seal pup. Engage in a stand-off with China on Taiwan – taking media attention to conflict overseas, your highest poll ratings have always been correlated to military conflict abroad (Bush Sr. playbook).
- Team Biden: Double down on the Wheaties, you cannot grapple with Trump – so don’t engage, stick to you script. Be even more assertive & don’t aske for your time back – take it, you are gunning for the seat of POTUS, you need to have the backbone of +330m Americans, including the +200K that have died along with the suffering that has brought to their families.
- Don’t be afraid of not outlining how much of a cluster $%@! the administration response has been to the virus compared to other countries, i.e. its not just about the context of 4% of global population with 20% of the deaths (which is powerful context), but also the emotion & visceral delivery of that – “It’s a goddam tragedy & disgrace… & you (Trump) should be charged for war crimes + gross negligence”
- When interrupted restart your segment with the intent of using the full 2mins, otherwise whatever good points you may have are diluted & cut up into bits. Continue to highlight that it was very evident that administration new about the virus – intelligence reports going back to Jan & Feb that were ignored.
- Lastly on economy, again you brought it back from death in the Obama | Biden administration, so you can do this again under a Biden | Harris administration – also don’t forget you have literally set history with pushing Obama to run, as well as in picking Harris for your running mate… Trump should not be able to run over you on anything to do with the black vote (this was a big miss in the 1st debate, make sure to remind ‘Merica!).
Dragon Must Reads...
- We keep hearing about “K”, catch the latest Steen’s Chronicle: Beware the implications of the K-Shape future (hint more divergence than we have seen so far!)
Why the letter K defines society, economics, politics and markets - plus how this new macro model impact the construction of your portfolio going forward.
- John Hardy dropping a roadmap US Election Primer: The Final Sprint to November 3rd
We sort through important dates in this final sprint phase of the absurdly long US presidential election cycle. Historically, we have seen significant shifts in the polling in the final weeks leading up to the election. As well, we consider factors that can change the odds between now and Election Day on November 3rd.
- Saxo’s US Election Cheat Sheet Which cuts into the three potential pathways into the elections, probabilities around them, as well as short & long-term positions across equities, bonds, commodities & currencies.
Start-to-End = Gratitude + Integrity + Vision + Tenacity. Process > Outcome. Sizing > Idea.
This is the wayKVP
Latest Market Insights
Outrageous Predictions 2023: The War Economy
- The constantly growing global need for energy drives the world's richest to huddle up and launch a R&D project in a size the world hasn't seen since the Manhattan Project gave the US the first atomic bomb.
French President Macron resignsThe political stalemate in France and the rise of Marie Le Pen following the 2022 elections corners President Macron, forcing him to give up on politics and resign from his position. At least for now.
Gold rockets to USD 3,000 as central banks fail on inflation mandateAs markets and central banks realise that the idea that inflation is transitory is wrong, and that prices will remain higher for longer, gold is sent through the roof, hitting a price tag of USD 3,000
EU Army forces EU down path to full unionWith continued challenges in the region and a US military that isn't aggressively enacting its former role as global policeman, the European Union agrees to create its own armed forces, bringing the whole region closer.
A country agrees to ban all meat production by 2030In an effort to become one of the global leaders on the path to net-zero emissions, one country decides to not only put a heavy tax on meat, but to ban domestic production entirely.
UK holds UnBrexit referendumFollowing a recession and domestic pressure, the United Kingdom is thrown into political turmoil that will end with a vote to wind back Brexit.
Widespread price controls are introduced to cap official inflationHistory tells us that with the war economy comes rationing and price controls. And this time is no different, as policymakers introduce strict price controls that lead to a range of unintended consequences.
OPEC+ & Chindia walk out of the IMF, agree to trade with new reserve assetSanctions against Russia have caused widespread turmoil due to US Dollar moves in countries across the globe that don't consider the US an ally. To relieve themselves from this, they leave the IMF and create a new reserve asset.
USDJPY fixed to the USD at 200 as Japan overhauls financial systemFollowing the challenges that faced the Japanese Yen in 2022, the Bank of Japan attempts to keep the currency from sliding. Unsuccessful on the long-term, Japan will launch a reset of its entire financial system.
Tax haven ban kills private equityWith the war economy comes an increased focus on national interests and sovereign nations' ability to assert themselves. In that regard, the OECD countries turn their attention on tax havens and pull the big guns out, banning them altogether.