Quarterly Outlook
Q1 Outlook for Traders: Five Big Questions and Three Grey Swans.
John J. Hardy
Global Head of Macro Strategy
Luxury shares are attracting renewed interest, but recent results reveal a widening gap between strong brands and struggling rivals.
Jewellery and ultra-wealthy customers remain relatively resilient, while aspirational shoppers are proving harder to win back.
For investors, lasting profitability, genuine pricing power and reasonable valuations matter more than a fashionable recovery story.
Paris is polishing its finest packaging. From 17 to 19 November, Les Places d’Or brings luxury designers and suppliers to the Hôtel Le Meurice. European luxury shares also gained ground on Monday as technology stocks weakened.
But attractive packaging does not guarantee what investors really need: repeat customers and lasting profits.
The industry's latest results suggest a recovery, just not one shared equally.
Richemont, owner of Cartier and Van Cleef & Arpels, reported 17% sales growth for the six months to September. Jewellery rose 19%. Yet growth slowed in the latest quarter, reminding investors that even excellent results can disappoint when expectations are higher.
Hermès remains comparatively resilient, although quarterly sales growth moderated to 4%. Meanwhile, Brunello Cucinelli grew third-quarter revenue 13.5%, while Zegna's namesake brand advanced 12.7% organically.
The common thread is not simply high prices. Distinctive products, controlled distribution and relationships with wealthy customers can sustain demand when occasional luxury buyers retreat.
A difficult market reveals something that strong markets often hide: which brands customers genuinely cannot replace.
LVMH, behind Louis Vuitton and Dior, reported a 5% organic sales decline in fashion and leather goods last quarter. Gucci, Kering's largest brand, fell 6%.
Burberry offers a more encouraging turnaround story. Comparable store sales rose 4%, suggesting its renewed focus on iconic trench coats and scarves is reconnecting with customers.
The middle ground is equally revealing. Prada Group's nine-month revenue grew 15% at constant currencies, but only 4% organically, excluding portfolio changes. Miu Miu's sales slipped in the latest quarter. Moncler's namesake brand declined 1%, while Ferragamo's directly operated sales improved despite wholesale weakness.
The lesson is simple: a sector can recover while individual brands continue losing customers. And a turnaround is not complete simply because sales stop falling.
For years, luxury houses raised prices without losing many customers. That works until shoppers decide the product no longer justifies the premium.
The strongest brands protect exclusivity without depending on constant price increases. Others face a difficult choice: offer more accessible products or risk weaker demand. Neither comes without consequences.
Investors must also distinguish sales from profits. Richemont's reported margins benefited from one-off tariff items, while Burberry's improving earnings still accompanied negative first-half free cash flow.
Strong revenue is encouraging. Strong revenue that translates into sustainable cash generation is far more valuable.
Paris's luxury showcase celebrates the details that transform an ordinary object into something desirable. Investors face a similar task, but must look beyond appearances.
Luxury remains an attractive business when craftsmanship, scarcity and customer loyalty support healthy margins over decades. Yet recent results show these qualities are unevenly distributed.
A stronger Chinese consumer, renewed tourism or a successful collection could support a broader recovery. Equally, weak demand or excessive valuations could disappoint shareholders even when businesses improve.
The question is no longer whether people still want luxury. Clearly, many do. It is which brands can persuade them to return, pay full price and keep coming back. A beautiful box is helpful. The business inside matters more.