3 mistakes investors make in selloffs

Key points:

• Big selloffs often reflect market mechanics, not broken long-term theses: Sharp drops in any crowded, liquid area (equities, tech, commodities) can spill into other assets via de-risking, liquidity selling, and USD/rates repricing— without changing the long-term fundamentals.
• Diversification doesn’t mean zero volatility: In stress, correlations rise and even “defensive” holdings can wobble. If volatility forces decisions, the issue is usually sizing and process, not whether you picked the “wrong” asset class.
• The biggest risk is turning short-term volatility into a permanent decision: Successful long-term investors rebalance exposure, not emotions. A bad week tests discipline – it doesn’t require perfect timing or a new narrative.

What the silver and precious-metals slide tells us about cross-asset volatility

If you’ve been watching markets lately and thinking, “Why is everything moving at once?” — you’re not alone.

The recent drop in silver and precious metals matters beyond metals itself because sharp moves in a “big, liquid” market can spill over into other assets. Here’s the investor-friendly version of what’s going on:

• Metals are widely held and widely traded, often with leverage in parts of the market.
• When prices fall quickly, it can trigger margin calls, forced selling, and de-risking.
• And when investors need cash fast, they often sell what they can, not necessarily what they want — which can pressure other liquid markets too (equities, FX, even parts of credit).
• Add in a volatile mix of USD and rates repricing, and you get the classic cross-asset effect: volatility doesn’t stay in one corner.

So even if you don’t own silver, a sharp move in metals can still show up as wider swings across portfolios.

For long-term investors, the key is not to get pulled into the “everything is breaking” narrative. Selloffs are stressful, but they’re also revealing: they show where process is strong — and where behaviour can cause avoidable damage.

Here are three common mistakes selloffs expose — and the simple mindset shifts that help avoid them.

Mistake #1: Treating a big move as a new long-term truth

Sharp price moves look like information — but speed doesn’t equal significance.

Metal selloffs can be driven by short-term forces:

• positioning and leverage unwinds after a strong run
• sudden shifts in rates or the US dollar
• investors selling liquid assets to raise cash

These drivers can dominate for days or weeks without changing the longer-term role metals may play as a diversifier.

A useful discipline:
Before acting, write one sentence:
“What changed, and will it still matter in 6–12 months?”

If you can’t answer clearly, the move is probably market mechanics, not a structural verdict.

Mistake #2: Expecting diversifiers to be calm all the time

Gold and silver are often treated as “stability assets,” but in stressed markets they can drop sharply — especially when:

• the US dollar strengthens
• real yields rise
• cash-raising turns into forced selling

That doesn’t mean diversification failed. It means stress changes behaviour: investors sell what’s liquid.

The real test:
If a 10–20% swing forces an emotional decision, the issue is usually position size, not asset choice.

Mistake #3: Turning volatility into a timing decision

This is the most damaging mistake — and the most common.

Many long-term investors sell during selloffs not because their thesis changed, but because discomfort did. The idea is often “I’ll re-enter later,” but re-entry rarely happens cleanly — and markets don’t ring a bell when the dust has settled.

Volatility turns temporary moves into permanent portfolio decisions.

A better response:

• Don’t rebalance your emotions
• Rebalance your weights

If an asset still belongs in a long-term plan, the question is often how much, not whether.

Why boring often works better than bold

The most resilient portfolios are rarely exciting. They’re built around:

• diversification across drivers
• conservative sizing
• periodic rebalancing
• patience through uncomfortable periods

Selloffs are less a test of market knowledge and more a test of discipline. Consistency usually matters more than conviction.

The bottom line for long-term investors

If you bought metals as part of a multi-year strategy:

• A volatile week doesn’t require a new narrative
• A sharp drawdown doesn’t demand perfect timing
• And a selloff doesn’t invalidate diversification

The investors who compound successfully over time are not the ones who avoid every drawdown — they are the ones who avoid turning drawdowns into decisions they can’t undo.