Beyond the discounts: what Black Friday could tell us about the economy
Key takeaways
Black Friday offers a global test of consumer spending, confidence and purchasing power.
This week's US and Chinese retail earnings will provide early clues about the strength of holiday demand.
Strong sales do not guarantee strong profits. Pricing power, margins and inventory management matter just as much.
A discounted television can tell us surprisingly much about the economy. Is someone buying it because they feel financially comfortable, or because the price is finally low enough?
With Black Friday approaching on 27 November, the Christmas shopping season is gathering momentum across the world. Before the big weekend, some of America's largest retailers, including Walmart, Target, Home Depot and Lowe's, report earnings this week. China's e-commerce giants Alibaba, JD.com and PDD Holdings will also open their books, following the country's Singles' Day shopping festival.
For investors, the question is not simply how much people spend. It is what their spending reveals about the economy, and which businesses can turn that demand into sustainable profits.
America: a full shopping trolley tells only half the story
The National Retail Federation expects US holiday sales to grow 4.2% this year, exceeding 1 trillion USD for the first time.
Encouraging, but higher spending does not necessarily mean households are buying more. If prices rise, consumers can spend more while taking home fewer products. October's US retail sales figures, due on 17 November, will offer another clue.
This week's earnings provide a more detailed picture.
Walmart's strength in groceries and everyday essentials makes it a useful indicator of household budgets. Target, with greater exposure to clothing and home furnishings, offers a window into spending on non-essential goods.
Home Depot and Lowe's tell another story. Higher borrowing costs and a subdued housing market can encourage homeowners to postpone expensive renovations. A new kitchen is easier to delay than the weekly grocery shop.
For investors, management's outlook for the coming months may matter more than last quarter's results.
Europe: selling the jumper without giving away the profit
Europe presents a somewhat different picture. Retail sales volumes in the euro area fell 0.7% in September compared with August, although they remained slightly higher than a year earlier.
Black Friday will test whether European shoppers are becoming more comfortable spending on non-essential goods.
Fashion retailers such as Inditex (owner of Zara), H&M and online platform Zalando offer useful perspectives. Their challenge is not simply getting customers through the door, or onto the website, but doing so profitably.
Consider Inditex. In the first half of 2026, sales grew 7.6%, while its gross profit margin increased to 58.7%. This is the share of revenue left after covering the cost of products sold.
Its ability to respond quickly to changing fashion trends helps reduce the risk of unsold clothing. That matters because a retailer with too many winter coats in January may have little choice but to cut prices.
China: when discounts become the business model
China has already had its own shopping test. Singles' Day, centred on 11 November, generated sales growth of 4.8% this year, according to data provider Syntun, down from 14.2% last year.
Alibaba, JD.com and PDD Holdings are competing for cautious consumers through promotions, subsidies and increasingly sophisticated shopping tools.
The battle extends beyond China. PDD's international platform Temu competes for bargain hunters globally, adding pressure on established retailers. Amazon faces a similar challenge: keeping customers loyal while maintaining profitability.
The risk is that retailers increasingly need discounts just to maintain sales. A successful shopping event can also bring forward purchases that consumers would otherwise make in December.
Investor playbook: look beyond the checkout
- Watch margins: rising sales alongside falling margins may signal that retailers are buying growth through discounts.
- Check inventory: excess stock can mean further price cuts and cash tied up in unsold products.
- Compare customer behaviour: strength in groceries but weakness in fashion or home improvement may indicate households are becoming more cautious.
- Mind the valuation: even a high-quality retailer can disappoint shareholders if its share price already assumes exceptional growth.
A good bargain for whom?
Black Friday will generate plenty of headlines about record spending, bestselling products and impressive discounts. But the most interesting numbers for investors may arrive weeks later, when retailers reveal how much profit they actually made.
A strong shopping season could be welcome news for the global economy. It could also reveal which businesses have built genuine competitive advantages through trusted brands, efficient operations and loyal customers.
For shoppers, the best bargain might be a television at half price. For investors, the better bargain may be a business that customers return to even when the sale is over, provided its shares come at a reasonable price.