The oil and gas industry desperately needs higher prices
Head of Equity Strategy
Summary: Natural gas prices went below $2/MMBtu in today's session in almost unbearable territory making it even worse for the industry to service its debt and deliver returns to its shareholders. The energy sector has been structurally weak after the financial crisis with too high cost levels and debt overhang to deliver return on capital levels above the cost of capital. This is clearly unsustainable and the industry desperately needs higher prices or else bankruptcies will force the discipline and reign in supply to increase prices. Inflation might be the unpleasant force lurking underneath the unsustainable oil and gas industry.
The oil and gas industry is in trouble seen by the latest restructuring attempt by Chesapeake Energy and this weekend that McDermott International is preparing to file for bankruptcy. As we talked about in today’s Market Call natural gas prices went below $2/MMBtu in today’s session during what should have been the strong season and with the frightening outlook that the US gas industry is running out of time to get “its” winter. The troubles are evident despite low rates and a world economy still in expansion mode. Five years of walking in the desert could the energy be close to an important inflection point with rising prices and profitability?
Structural break since 2008
One of the key observations in the global energy sector is rising cost structure in the sector. During the period 2003-2008 the sector delivered easily +15% return on equity (ROE) but post the financial crisis we observe a distinct lower profitability at equal oil price levels. Take today’s Brent crude price of $65/brl and compare the two periods. In the early period the sector delivered +25% ROE at these price levels whereas the most recent period the ROE has been closer to 5-10%. These returns are not enough to satisfy the required rate of return from investors given the general equity return required and then adding sector risks such as cyclicality risk, elevated credit risk, “black” energy discount etc. The sector is essentially destroying capital at current levels and investments made for new discoveries have also been reduced substantially.
Many value investors have wrongly pointed at low valuation levels and fat dividends as arguments for buying the energy sector. We have basically been negative on the sector since 2015 when prices collapsed and all the metrics became so toxic that the entire operating model became defunct. The last five years have proven that value investors need more than valuations and dividends. If an entire sector is not operating at sustainable and attractive return on capital levels then the sector goes nowhere. The energy sector has delivered zero percent including dividends the past five years compared to the global equity market up almost 60% in the same period. If we can get the necessary bankruptcies to curb supply instead of relying on OPEC+ then we will endorse the sector with an overweight view, but for now the risks are still too high. But 2020 could be the year where the oil and gas industry becomes an opportunity despite the ongoing flood wave of green investments.
Debt load and inflation
What makes the situation even more dangerous for the energy sector is the leveraging that has accelerated since the price collapse in 2015. For 10 years the sector operated with stable low net-debt-to-EBITDA multiple but after 2015 this metric deteriorated badly and has now settled at levels four times the golden period from 2003-2008. With low rates the sector is barely managing the debt levels but if the world gets higher interest rates the fallout in the energy sector could be severe. What is interesting about the dynamics in the energy sector is that the low interest rates have sustained oil production and increased it substantially through debt financing. This is has caused oil supply to increase to levels compressing the oil price to such levels where the sector suddenly destroys credit and equity value. That’s an irony even in the world of Silicon Valley unicorns descending on Wall Street.
We are likely moving closer to a forced wave of bankruptcies and restructurings that could cause a material slowdown of oil production which would lift prices and profitability for the companies standing up after the reset. But higher energy prices mean higher inflation which could lead to higher interest rates which would then cause distress for more energy companies. A vicious feedback loop could happen. If investors want to get exposure to the energy sector we believe the best way to do it is by getting exposure to the energy companies with solid balance sheet and strong return on capital metrics.
Any way you look at it the industry needs higher prices or some new technology that unlocks efficiency gains that are large enough to operate profitable at current levels. The industry needs sustained oil prices above $80/brl to deliver the return on capital long-term that makes the sector viable for creditors and equity investors.
Latest Market Insights
Q4 Outlook 2022: Winter is coming
- Winter is coming to the financial markets as central banks are tightening their grip. How spring will look is still a question.
European energy crisis: it will get worse before it gets betterThe winter in Europe will be tough, but whether the result is political chaos or sustainable, innovative solutions is still undecided.
A difficult and volatile quarter awaitsAs the year draws to an end, commodities continue to be at centre stage of the world with growth pockets political uncertainty.
The bright side: crises drive innovationThe positive spin on crises is that they come with solutions. It is worrisome that deglobalisation may be a response to this crisis.
Green transformation in China: renewable energy and beyondGoing green, China needs to span numerous energy sources to ensure stability, as every source comes with a challenge.
Asia: Intermittent solutions, but a faster renewable adoption curveAsian energy supply is being squeezed. This and the adoption of renewables may change the investment sentiment in the region.
FX: A Fed thaw needed to deliver a sustained USD turn lowerThe US Dollar can keep momentum when the Federal Reserve continues to tighten, leaving the rest to play to their drum.
Autumn can become ugly for equities and bond holders. Comfort for Dollar longsTechnical analysis suggests that equities could face a tough Q4 as could fixed income. US Dollar positions could provide some upside.
The next stock market sector to watch, with stocks going nuclearAs the world scrambles to find affordable, sustainable energy, nuclear is getting attention from politicians and investors alike.
The crypto space is getting cold when the hype disappearsCryptocurrencies face a winter of their own as retail investors and governments are asking tough questions.