Gold's dilemma: Structural demand tested by dollar strength and rising funding costs
Key Points:
- Gold under pressure: Rising US rate expectations, higher yields and dollar strength drive gold to a 15-month low, delaying prospects for recovery.
- Dollar liquidity concerns intensify: Rising funding costs and demand for cash risk triggering further liquidation across commodities and other popular investments.
- Silver's spectacular reversal: Silver has plunged more than 60% from its January peak, pressured by speculative unwinding, weaker industrial demand and growth concerns.
- Structural support remains: Resilient ETF holdings and central bank demand underpin gold's longer-term outlook, but a sustained recovery likely requires easing inflation, yields and dollar strength.
Gold and silver have come under heavy selling pressure in recent weeks as rising US interest-rate expectations, elevated bond yields and dollar strength undermine investor confidence. Both metals have fallen sharply this month, with gold down 4% and silver 8.4%, extending their year-to-date losses to 14% and 36%, respectively. Gold touched a fresh 15-month low at USD 3,694 an ounce in Thursday's Asian session, while silver briefly traded at USD 44.55, its weakest level in 14 months.
The question is whether the selloff reflects a fundamental change in the longer-term investment case for precious metals or a cyclical adjustment driven by increasingly restrictive financial conditions. We continue to favour the latter interpretation, although a sustainable recovery now appears further away than previously expected.
Inflation, higher yields and the dollar deliver a triple blow
The inflationary consequences of this year's Middle East conflict continue to reverberate through financial markets. The energy-led surge in inflation, followed by broader price pressures, has forced investors to reassess the US monetary policy outlook. Since the conflict began, when Fed funds were trading at 3.75%, expectations for the March 2027 policy rate have shifted from around 3% to 4.5%, driving Treasury yields and the dollar sharply higher.
Hawkish comments from Fed Governor Christopher Waller, who raised the possibility of a 50-basis-point December hike or accelerated tightening in 2027, together with the latest FOMC minutes, have reinforced expectations that monetary policy may remain restrictive for longer. For gold, higher real yields increase the opportunity cost of holding a non-interest-bearing asset, while a stronger dollar makes the metal more expensive for investors using other currencies.
Is dollar liquidity becoming the bigger problem?
Beyond interest-rate differentials, tightening dollar liquidity may also be contributing to the broader selloff across commodities and other previously popular investments. Rising financing requirements linked to AI infrastructure, IPO activity, equity market volatility and elevated energy security costs may be increasing demand for cash just as higher rates make borrowing more expensive. Combined with early year-end profit-taking and reduced leveraged exposure, these developments risk creating a self-reinforcing cycle of dollar demand and asset liquidation.
Gold is particularly vulnerable during such periods, not because its longer-term appeal has necessarily diminished, but because its deep liquidity makes it an accessible source of cash. Investors facing higher funding costs, margin requirements or portfolio losses elsewhere may be forced to sell assets they would otherwise prefer to hold.
While dollar strength alone does not establish that the global financial system is experiencing a funding shortage, the risk deserves attention, particularly if equity market weakness persists.
ETF resilience provides an important counterweight
Against this difficult backdrop, gold ETF investors have shown remarkable resilience. Despite sharply lower prices and rising opportunity costs, aggregate holdings remain close to recent highs. This contrasts with heavy speculative selling elsewhere in precious metals and suggests that many investors continue to view gold as a strategic portfolio allocation rather than a short-term trade.
A sustained liquidation of these holdings would remove an important source of support. Conversely, if ETF demand remains stable while speculative positions are reduced, the market may be laying the groundwork for a more durable recovery once macroeconomic conditions improve.
The immediate risk is that deteriorating dollar liquidity or another sharp equity correction eventually forces even longer-term investors to reduce exposure. ETF flows, equity market stability and dollar funding conditions will therefore be important indicators to monitor.
As the charts illustrate, gold and the Bloomberg Dollar Spot Index have exhibited a pronounced inverse relationship this year, with the dollar's latest breakout to its strongest level since April 2025 accompanying another sharp decline in gold. ETF holdings meanwhile, remain close to recent highs despite the mentioned headwinds.
Silver's speculative excess continues to unwind
Silver faces the same monetary headwinds as gold, compounded by a weaker industrial demand outlook and the continued unwinding of speculative excesses that drove prices to extraordinary levels earlier this year.
Having surged above USD 120 an ounce in January, silver has since collapsed by more than 60%. Extreme volatility has discouraged financial investment, while elevated prices accelerated substitution and demand destruction in some industrial applications. More recently, concerns about slowing activity in China have added pressure, also contributing to Wednesday's 5% slump in copper.
The correction is now historically extreme. Silver trades around 50% below its 200-day moving average, a negative deviation last seen in 2013. Gold, meanwhile, is approximately 18% below its equivalent average, also its most stretched downside reading since 2013.
Such extremes increase the potential for a sharp technical rebound, but oversold conditions alone cannot establish a sustainable bottom while borrowing costs remain elevated and growth concerns persist.
What could reverse the trend?
The clearest catalyst would be convincing evidence that US inflation is moderating. The recent decline in crude oil and refined fuel prices offers some encouragement, particularly if sustained long enough to reduce headline inflation and broader cost pressures. However, the Fed will need reassurance that inflation is slowing beyond energy-related components before adopting a less hawkish stance.
Lower inflation could ease expectations for further rate hikes, bring Treasury yields lower and weaken the dollar's interest-rate advantage. This would also help alleviate funding pressures and encourage investors to rebuild exposure to commodities and other dollar-sensitive assets.
Equity market stabilisation would provide another important signal, reducing the risk of forced liquidation as investors rebuild liquidity buffers.
Structural support remains, but patience is required
Despite the current weakness, our longer-term outlook for gold remains constructive. Central bank buying remains an important source of structural demand, supported by reserve diversification, geopolitical uncertainty and concerns surrounding the long-term fiscal outlook of major Western economies.
The World Gold Council estimates that central banks purchased 321 tonnes during the third quarter, bringing purchases during the first nine months of 2026 to 675 tonnes, demonstrating the persistence of official-sector demand despite market volatility.
However, this structural demand should not be mistaken for an unconditional price floor. Central banks are not immune to tighter dollar liquidity, particularly in emerging economies facing currency depreciation, higher energy import bills or mounting external financing requirements. Such pressures may temporarily reduce purchases or, in some cases, trigger gold sales to meet liquidity needs.
The distinction is important: while reserve diversification provides a powerful long-term source of demand, it cannot necessarily prevent sharp cyclical corrections or offset forced selling by financial investors. The resilience of central bank purchases through the current tightening cycle will therefore be an important test of gold's underlying support.
Our central scenario remains one in which structural demand helps cushion the downside through the Fed tightening cycle, while an eventual shift towards monetary easing, potentially from mid- to late 2027, could provide the conditions needed for private investment demand to recover.
Lower real yields, a less dominant dollar and renewed investor focus on fiscal sustainability and monetary credibility could ultimately restore gold's appeal as a portfolio diversifier and hedge against longer-term macroeconomic risks.
For now, however, the dollar remains the dominant force. Gold and silver may already be oversold based on parameters such as RSI and distance to their 200-day moving averages, but a sustained recovery requires more than attractive valuations. It needs evidence that inflation, yields and dollar funding pressures are finally beginning to ease.
| Related articles/content |
|---|
| 18 Nov 2026: Commodities retreat as dollar strength and rate hike fears trigger broad liquidation 18 Nov 2026: Copper Short-term demand fears collide with long-term supply constraints 17 Nov 2026: COT on forex and commodities - Week to 10 November 2026 13 Nov 2026: Commodities weekly Inflation surprise weighs on metals as energy markets diverge 12 Nov 2026: Oil supply recovers but no war no peace keeps escalation risks elevated 11 Nov 2026: Gold challenges the Feds hawkish rate outlook Daily podcasts hosted by John J Hardy can be found here |
| More from the author |
|---|
|